Käpt'n Korky

Favourite Belles

24 posts in this topic

Hello everyone,

this idea came to me since it's every now and then a topic that heats up in the Forum and on the discord:
Who's you favourite Belle?

Maybe it would be interesting who it is for the average captain. So why not start a Topic about it.

My idea is to show a Top 10 of the most liked Belles. For all with a weak memory this is the link to Shiros list of Belles.

It works like this: You post here or send me a list of your (up to) 10 favourite Belles, and I will compose a ranking out ouf it. Your top 1 gets 10 points, top 2 gets 9 points all down to 10 who gets 1 point.

TOP 10 (please read after you made you list).

 

1. Mahan 54p

2. Scharnhorst 38p
    Kirov 38p

3. Hans Lüdemann 37p

4. Nagato 36p

5. New Orleans 29p   

6. Orion 22p

7. Gneisenau 26p
    Nevada 26p
    Algerie 26p

8. Leberecht Maass 24p

9. Hood 23p

10. Ark Royal 22p
    De Ruyter 22p
    Nerpa 22p

(04.09.2017)

Some additional data:

Spoiler

Navy count: 

1. Kriegsmarine 181p total, 22,63 per ship (8 ships)

2. US Navy        157p total, 15,7 per ship (10 ships)

3. Royal Navy      126p total, 14 per ship (9 ships)

4. Japan Navy     124p total, 12,4 per ship (10 ships)

5. Soviet Navy     109p total, 21,8 per ship (5 ships)

6. Italian Navy     44p total, 14,66 per ship (3 ships)

7. French Navy   35p total, 7 per ship (5 ships)

8. Dutch Navy     22p total, 22 per ship (1 ship)

9. Polish Navy      16p total, 7 per ship (1 ship)

10. Spanish Navy9p total, 4,5 per ship (2 ships)7777 777

Most mentioned: Kirov, Mahan, Scharnhorst each 7 times; D'Aosta 6 times; Gneisenau, Kongou, Nagato, New Orleans, Hans Lüdemann, Algérie each 5 times

Adjusted to all nonsense: 
Graf Spee 61p, kicks Ark, De Ruyter and Nerpa off the list and takes 1st place. And Scharnhorst is scrapped from the list. Nerpa, well everyone can see it atm.

Up to Shirogane I had to always add at least one ship to the list.

The only minor navy missing a ship metioned now is Turkey. And the Kriegsmarine is the only major navy with all ships liked by someone.

My list:

1. Gneisenau

2. Scharnhorst

3. Hans Lüdemann

4. Leberecht Maass

5. De Ruyter

6. Espero

7. Kirov

8. Hiriyu

9. D'Aosta

10. New Orleans

I hope some will like the idea. Sincerely, Korky

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just found out about this game a week ago and I've gotta say it looks amazing. Glad to see the board is still active. Great topic btw.

1. Nevada

2. Hood

3. Orion

4. Salt lake

5. New Orleans

6. Algerie

7. Mississippi

8.Ark Royal

9. Nautilus

10. Scharnhorst

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My top 5 are in my signature. (If you don't accept 4 of those because you're a filthy oppressor of my freedom of love, I've added 11-14)

1. Admiral Graf Spee

2. Admiral Graf Spee

3. Admiral Graf Spee

4. Admiral Graf Spee

5. Admiral Graf Spee

6. Nagato

7. Diether Von Roeder

8. Lebrecht Maass

9. Scharnhorst

10. Nenohi

11. Gneisenau

12. Algerie

13. D'Aosta

14. Nerpa (It was between her and Kirov, but the fact that she's not a commie won out)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My top 12 (which will surprise no one):

1: Pupper (Bulldog)

2: Hood

3: Rawa

4: Orion

4.5: Kongou

5: Houston

6: New Orleans

7: Parizhskaya Kommuna

8: Ark Royal

9: Gneissenau

10: Z18

11: Duca D'Aosta

12: Stewart

...

666: Pola

...

Very bottom of the list: Spee

...

On the list of "To Be Scrapped": Scharnhorst

:P

(Edit: had to edit to be fair and balans)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I can't really make a top 10 but let's see. Hmm.

  1. Belfast
  2. Mahan
  3. D'aosta
  4. Ark Royal
  5. Leningrad
  6. Nenohi
  7. Kirov
  8. Lexington
  9. Boise
  10. Hiryu

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Nevada

2. Mahan

3. Hans Ludemann

4. Leningrad

5. Graff Spee

6. Hood

7. Gneissenau

8. Scharnhorst

9. Kirov

10. Verdun

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

In no particular order besides the obvious. 

 

Ark Royal

Nagato

U-29

Gneisenau

Scharnhorst

Mahan

Algiers 

Kirov

Kongou 

Rawalpindi 

Honorable mention:

Italian mystery sisters with the wildly different letter writing styles. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Now I don't post a lot but u want to toss my hat in to the ring
 

  1. Mahan
  2. Z18 (Hans Lüdemann)
  3. Leningrad
  4. Espero
  5. Nautilus
  6. Velasco
  7. Henley
  8. Salt Lake City 
  9. Bulldog
  10. Boise

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Back from Davie's depths I come, to give my best their proper due!

1) Парижская коммуна

2) Nagato

3) Профинтерн

4) Mahan

5) Киров

6) Leberecht Maass

7) Z17

8) Nevada

9) Kumano

10) Aoba

-1) щ-205 Нерпа

The traitor must dissapear! Long live the Union! (since she's the first on my Negative list, she loses 10 points. That's how it works, right?)

Also, a very special mention to USS Salt Lake City! I can't say her belle made my list, but the ship itself is always going to be on my top 10!

From there, back to the depths I go......

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is tougher then I thought, but I think I hammered out a list 

1. Mahan

2. New Orleans

3. Nerpa 

4. Kitakami

5. Auxum 

6. Lexington

7. Mississippi

8. Kongou

9. Z-17

10. Dunkerque

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Let's see if we can get some hot dev action in here!  @Legate of Mineta Can you get us a list of the top 10 belles from each Dev Department?  Or at least your own list?

 

And maybe when we count them we'll send you the totals and you can publish them in the next update!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@Legate of Mineta

lets get the devs side of things shall we?

I may need a industrial size bag of popcorn for this......

Eating-Popcorn-Soda.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Kirov

2. Perth

3. Scharnhorst

4. ORP Wicher 

5. Nagato

6. Leberecht Maass

7. De Ruyter

8. Nevada

9. Lexington

10. D'Aosta

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hard to rank the latter ones buuuuut:

  1. Belfast
  2. New Orleans
  3. De Ruyter
  4. PK
  5. Nerpa
  6. Scharnhorst
  7. Mahan
  8. Nagato
  9. Kongou
  10. Stuart

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bahaha!

Impossible! Too much [Redacted] on that list, although some of the revealed Belles *are* favorites around the Team. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, Legate of Mineta said:

Bahaha!

Impossible! Too much [Redacted] on that list, although some of the revealed Belles *are* favorites around the Team. :)

Can you ask them to pick their favorites of Shiro's revealed list?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ninja;

While I'll certainly ask, I would *think* that the Team's favorites will always be hard to describe, since they are all our children. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Legate of Mineta said:

...since they are all our children. :)

Why do I now wish I could draw so that I could render a line of baby Belles along the lines of "Muppet Babies"? :-)  

Oh the kawaii in my head right now!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I thoroughly agree with the kind doctor that we need Child belles drawn now.  I think a collective picture at a playground would be absolutely adorable.
 

As for the team, if they anonymously present their favorites, none of the belles have to find out who picked who, and they can remain confident the belles don't harbor ill feelings to them.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Before I wrote the list, I read all the interviews completely,then:

1. Nürnberg

2. Киров

3.Kumano

4.Orion

5.Nenohi

6.Hans Ludemann

7.De Ruyter

8.U-29

9.D'Aosta

10.Kougou

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 9/1/2017 at 2:37 AM, DrYuriMom said:

Why do I now wish I could draw so that I could render a line of baby Belles along the lines of "Muppet Babies"? :-)  

Oh the kawaii in my head right now!

Anyone please make it happen! :)

I will refresh data probably on monday. Jfyi.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Axum
2. Aoba
3. Fubuki
4. Nerpa
5. Algérie
6. Kitakami
7. Maillé Brézé
8. La Motte-Picquet
9. Takoa
10. D'Aosta

Oh my. There's not a single capital ship on that list. I better get my hands on some Type 93s 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The french navy should send its regards to Urza. He just doubled its points and linked it to the other majors. He also helped the IJN nick place 4 from the soviets.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1.Fubuki

2.ORP Wicher

3.Algérie

4.Z18 Hans Lüdemann    

5.HMS Orion

6.Admiral Graf Spee

7.Canarias

8.Chiyoda

9.HMS Salmon

10.Takao

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now